Why surrendering endowment life insurance policy is a loss making

Surrendering an endowment life insurance policy before its maturity is often considered a loss-making decision for policyholders. This is primarily because the surrender value—the amount the insurance company pays if the policy is terminated prematurely—is usually significantly less than the total premiums paid.

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

Modern endowment plans may offer surrender value from the first year itself, but the amount is typically very low. This is due to high upfront costs, such as administrative charges and Advisor payouts. Early surrender leads to significant financial loss, emphasizing the importance of holding the policy long-term for better benefits. It is requested to buy a Life Insurance after collecting all information about it.

Here’s a comprehensive explanation on why surrendering an endowment policy leads to financial loss:

1. Understanding Endowment Policies

Endowment life insurance policies are designed to provide a combination of life cover and savings. Policyholders pay regular premiums over a specified term. If the insured survives the policy term, they receive a lump sum maturity benefit. In case of the policyholder’s death during the term, the nominee receives the death benefit. These policies aim to create long-term savings while offering financial protection.

However, the financial benefits of endowment policies are structured to reward long-term commitment. The surrender value is only a fraction of the total premiums paid, especially if the policy is surrendered early.

2. Structure of Premium Allocation

When a policyholder pays premiums, a portion goes towards providing life insurance coverage, while another portion covers administrative charges, agent commissions, and other fees. Only the remaining amount is invested to build the policy’s savings component.

In the initial years, these non-investment components consume a large part of the premium. Therefore, the surrender value—which is calculated based on the accumulated savings and bonuses—remains low in the early years. As a result, surrendering the policy early leads to a payout that is far below the total premiums paid.

3. Low Surrender Value in Early Years

Most insurance providers offer a surrender value only after premiums have been paid for at least two to three years. Even then, the value offered is minimal—often only 30% to 50% of the premiums paid, excluding the first year’s premium. Bonuses, if any, are rarely included in the surrender value unless the policy has been in force for a long duration.

For example, if a person pays annual premiums of ₹50,000 for three years, totaling ₹1,50,000, and decides to surrender the policy in the fourth year, the surrender value might be as low as ₹40,000 to ₹60,000. This means a loss of ₹90,000 to ₹110,000.

4. Loss of Compounded Growth and Bonuses

Endowment policies accrue bonuses over time, based on the insurer’s performance. These bonuses (reversionary and terminal) are usually paid at maturity or on death. By surrendering the policy early, the policyholder forfeits the potential of these future bonuses and the benefits of compounded returns.

Since the investment portion of the premium would have otherwise grown over time, early surrender cuts off this compounding effect, further reducing potential returns and exacerbating the financial loss.

5. Tax Implications

Another overlooked factor is the tax implication. Premiums paid for endowment policies are typically eligible for deductions under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act (in India), and maturity benefits are tax-free under Section 10(10D), provided certain conditions are met. However, if a policy is surrendered before completing five years, the tax benefits claimed earlier may become taxable, adding to the financial burden.

6. Better Alternatives for Liquidity

People often surrender endowment policies due to temporary financial crunches. However, taking a loan against the policy is usually a better alternative. Most endowment policies offer policy loans at relatively low interest rates. This helps retain the policy benefits while meeting short-term liquidity needs.

Summary

Surrendering an endowment life insurance policy is a loss-making move because the surrender value is typically much lower than the total premiums paid, especially in the early years. The policyholder not only loses a significant portion of their investment but also misses out on future bonuses and compounded returns. Additionally, they may face tax liabilities. Unless absolutely necessary, it is advisable to retain the policy or explore alternatives like loans against the policy rather than surrendering it. Long-term commitment is key to reaping the full benefits of endowment plans.